|
|
UK E-learning Reflections: UK leads the way or does it? |
| Saturday, January 20, 2007 |
Hi All:
I am just back from a long trip to the UK. Visited the University of Leicester for an annual conference January 9-10--presented on podcasts, wikis, and blogs as well as my research on Wikibooks. Then I presented the University of Oxford on January 11th on my research on blended learning in corporate training in 5 countries--UK, USA, China, Taiwan, and Korea as well as my wikibook research. It is always a delight to present at Oxford. The students have a contagious energy related to research on e-learning. We had students in the audience from Nepal, Taiwan, China, Korea, the UK, and other places. Very enthusiastic people and a lovely setting to speak in! On Friday the 12th, I presented at Coventry University on Podcasts, Wikis, and Blogs as well as on my SurveyShare tool.
My son, Alex, joined me for the weekend in London for sightseeing and the Chelsea vs. Wigan soccer game. See picture below of us celebrating the Chelsea 4-0 win with my good friend, Jim Hensman, from Coventry University.
  Later that evening, we also got to the Comedy Store--I love Brittish humor! Of course, my 19 year old son loved the chance to drink beer. Sunday was spent with Alex touring around London. He loved the Tower Bridge and the parliment area at night. Many pictures taken.
Monday the 15th was spent in Wales with a presentation to teachers on the future of ICT and schools at the University of Glamorgan. The 16th and 17th were spend in Derby speaking to more teachers on this topic. The 17th was devoted to speaking to teachers at Saint Benedict Catholic School and Performing Arts College in Derby. My talks there had many instructional techniques. Being Catholic (by birth), this was fun to do. It was my first time to speak at a Catholic school.
Had a bit of bad luck traveling in the UK this time. For instance, I got stuck in the Gatwick airport for an extra day on the way home. Our plane was grounded due to bad weather and high winds and problems with the flaps or something. So they put us up in the airport Hilton which was not a bad place. Anyway it is good to be home. I do not feel like a long trip for a long long time. This TravelEdMan is tired.
Ten Observations Related to E-Learning in the UK:
1. Standards and Benchmarks: People in the UK seem to be highly concerned with standards and benchmarks for e-learning. This has both positive and negative ramifications. On the negative side, are idea squelching statements and limitations related to creativity. On the positive side, it builds legidimacy for e-learning in that country and around the planet. For my money, this is the boring stuff of e-learning, but someone has to do it, so I will let them have their fun. I left the accounting world as a overly bored bean counter so this area does not thrill me much.
2. Blended Learning Research in the UK and 4 Other Countries: Our research on blended learning in corporate training in the UK, Korea, China, Taiwan, and the USA indicates that the UK is the leading country right now. Korea is a close second and the USA lags far back in 3rd. Then perhaps Taiwan and China, in that order. The UK has the highest percentage of companies incorporating blended learning and plans for increasing its use. However, unlike Korea and other Asian countries, they seem to lack frameworks for blended learning in their strategic plans. From a list of 15-20 different skills that can be taught through blended, corporations in the UK also rated ethic skill training last while Koreans rated it around #6. The Asian countries tended to emphasize basic skill (e.g., English) training through blended and the western countries were more focused on IT training. There is so much more data here and I am happy to share it. Just write me an email at cjbonk@indiana.edu or check out some of our publications at PublicationShare; see http://www.publicationshare.com/. For instance, see this early publication of the UK data:
Bonk, C. J., & Kim, K.-J. (2006, May). A survey of the present and future state of blended learning in corporate and other training settings - UK respondents. London, UK: The British Learning Association. Retrieved June 5, 2006, from http://www.british-learning.com/pdf/ukdata.pdf
This is the third major survey in a series of studies we have done on the present and future state of e-learning and blended learning. Earlier reports can be found at PublicationShare.com. 3. IT Resistance is Futile or is It? Teachers in the UK still seem very hesitant, reluctant, and resistant to ICT and e-learning. This may relate to point #1 above. Teachers in schools, in particular, did not seem to be incorporating new technologies such as podcasts, wikis, and blogs; though if they did, it was typically podcasts. However, it was interesting that I had car more teachers raising their hands in Wales that they were using these technologies during my talk at the University of Glamorgan, than I did when I asked the same thing of teachers in Derby. Admittedly, there were some higher education faculty in my talks in Wales which could be biasing these polling results. But, overall, there is still much hesitancy related to technology in education in the UK. My good friend, Dr. Michelle Selinger, from Cisco Systems, indicated that some reports related to the intergration of technology within schools in the UK are fairly depressing. I think she indicated that up to 80 percent of schools there were not effectively integrating technology.
4. Personalized Learning Environments: Of all the places I have visited, the UK seems the most focused on creating personalized learning environments or PLEs. At the ALT-C (Advanced Learning Technologies) conference on Edinburgh, Scotland in September, it was a key focus. PLEs were also rated the highest on my corporate training survey by UK participants. For my money, this is the direction that we can and should head.
5. Are Words Just Words? At the Beyond Distance Research Alliance Conference in Leicester on January 9-10 I heard the words globalization, creativity, and customization many times. It struck me as somewhat surprising to hear the word creativity given that it was not a conference theme or at least one that I was aware of. But were these just words coming from people's mouths that we could nod to in agreement? This was a great conference but I wanted to see some of this globalization and creativity displayed. Where was it?
6. OpenCourseWare Reaches the UK: The Open University in the UK has joined the opencourseware movement which MIT initiated several years ago (it is called OpenLearn; see http://openlearn.open.ac.uk/). While most of the links I found there were not working, it will be interesting to see the influence that this has. Opencourseware can dramatically change and enhance the learning opportunities of the people of this planet. MIT, Johns Hopkins, Tufts, the National University of Vietnam, Utah State, Waseda Unviersity in Japan, etc., may have been the first players in this game, but it will be highly interesting to see who jumps in next and for what purpose. Will the OU in the UK be highly influential or a strong participant? Why did they jump in now? How will the role of the BBC be here?
7. Polytechnics Embrace ICT and E-Learning: Of the 11 or so talks I did in the UK, I think my talks at Coventry University went the best. In particular, the one I did on podcasts, wikis, and blogs. Interestingly, Coventry University is a former polytechnic like many other places I have presented at in the UK over the past 2 years. Why is the former polytechnics who keep inviting me to speak (e.g., Leeds Metropolitan Univ, the Univ of Brighton, the Univ of Glamorgan, Anglia Ruskin University, Napier University, etc.), and not traditional university? Is it due to the age of the population that they serve? Are they more progressive and let set in their ways? Are they experimenting more with e-learning and blended learning? Will they be the universities of the future for the UK? What gives?
8. Open Source Courseware and Free Stuff: Seems, like in other places that I visit, everyone wants to know which open source software package to go with for a virtual learning environment (VLE) or as we call it in the States, a course management system (CMS). I here some moving to Moodle, others to Sakai, and still others to names I have not heard. Many in the UK have homegrown systems. The quest for open source, or at least more reasonably priced software is interesting. There might be money to be had for those interested in open source consulting in the UK.
9. UK E-Learning Connections Easier than US: It is relatively easy to connect people across the UK to discuss e-learning issues. People can get to the University of Leicester, for instance, in just 1-2 hours for the most part. It is a good central location for a conference. As I may have mentioned a year ago in my blog, this provides e-learning connections and discussions that we do not typically have here in the USA. While I do know many of the people who will show up for such discussions and debates in the UK, I have no clue who might in the USA. We are extremely disconnected and fractionated. It is unfortunate. This gives the leg up in terms of leadership in the e-learning space to the UK. Am I jealous? Perhaps yes. Perhaps no since I can always fly over and participate. But why aren't more from the USA and other places joining me if, in fact, the UK is a hub for all this e-learning and blended learning initiatives? (By the way, my journeys indicate that Canada is also a hub lately.)
10. Online Cheaters (If I said "plagiarism," I would not have as many readers): A question that I consistently get in the UK and elsewhere relates to plagiarism online. I have some 35 solutions (e.g., use TurnItIn.com, alter your exams, check text in a Google search for a match, tell students the consequences, have a training program in plagiarism, alter the test item sequence, sign an oath not to cheat, etc.), I have to repeat these every time. I need to include some of these in my next book on the Web of Learning--Part 2.
Ok, that is enough for now. Is the UK a leader in e-learning and blended learning. The answer is a definite yes. Is it THE leader--here I am not so sure. It has been fun going there 10 times in a little over 2 years. I had never visited there b4 in my life. I think I am done there for some time. Of course, as soon as I say that, I get an email from my friend Hadyn Blackey in Wales saying, hey come on back. Ok, we will see.
|
|
|
|
|
|
The 3 T's of Traveling: Taiwan, Taipei, and Thailand! |
| Friday, December 22, 2006 |
Wow, what a past 2 weeks this has been! I think I have crossed all my T's with visits to Taipei and other parts of Taiwan for a week followed by a trip to Thailand for a week.
Part 1: Taiwan. I am just home yesterday (December 21st) at about noon. Many former students met me in Taiwan. Great place! I got picked up at the airport by Victor Tao and his wife, Naoko Kihara. They had studied at Ohio University in Athens back in the 1990s (where they met), so we had many midwest stories to share. Naoko is about to start 2 Ph.D.'s and Victor is finishing his at National Taiwan University in Taipei.
Former IU master's student and now Ph.D., Dr. Jia-ling Lee, arranged for me to speak at Shih-Hsin University the following day. I talked on blended learning. After that, Jia-ling and 2 of her colleagues took me north on the subway to the sea to see on old Spanish fort (Santo Domingo?). That night former IU students (John Li, Mei-yun Tyan, Effie Chen, and Jalin Huang) took me to dinner at the Chiang Kai-Shek Memorial Hall cafe. It was so great to see everyone there! Lucifer Chu from the OOPS project also appeared. Effie then took me to a Chinese play of the Cloud Gate Dance Theater of Taiwan in the halls above--it was a best of the best of different shows. It was wonderful! So stunning, it is hard to describe here. Not sure if I have ever seen anything like it.
The following day, a former master's student from Applied Linguistics at IU, Jessie Chen, and her friend, Yu-Ling, took me to a number of places. After Jessie and I explored Taipei a bit, we went to the north to a seaside area by train and also the night market for dinner in Taipei.
Sunday, I have taken to Hsinshu which is about 1 hour south of the city. My guide was my trip coordinator, Dr. Sindy Peng (and her mother). On that day, I got a tour of a Haika village by former students, Dr. Mei-Ya Liang, and Dr. Ching-Fen Chang, both graduates of language education at IU though they did not know each other. Many xmas gifts where bought there. Dinner was spent with many former students including Ching-Fen and Mei-Ya and their families and also Feng-Kwei Wang and his family, Jiunde Lee (married to Yu - chen Hsu).
On Monday I visited a primary school which focused on creativity, art, and academics. Great place--the principal gave me a wooden Buddhist carving. Then I gave 2 talks at National Chiao Tung University which were attended by many of their students. Also in the audience were Mei-Ya's husband (Chen Chao (Kevin) Tao ), Dr. Chin-Chi Chao, Dr. Jalin Huang, and Dr. Grace Lin from the Univ of Houston (all friends of mine or former students). At the end, they gave me a wonderful gift--a wooden mini-me. Tuesday, I did a workshop for corporate trainers in Taipei on blended learning for the Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI). Feng-Kwei Wang who runs ITRI College and his assistant, Cindy Chen, arranged it. That night Victor and his wife Naoko and Grace Lin from the University of Houston and Lucifer Chu from OOPS (Opensource OpenCourseware Prototype System) met me for dinner. After dinner, we went to the top of Taipei 101--the tallest building in the world. Wednesday I gave a talk on podcasts, wikis, and blogs for a conference of the The Institute for Information Industry (III). This one went really good. In the afternoon, I went back to the Institute of Education, National Chiao Tung University for a talk on my research for Ching-Fen's students and colleague and others.
Dr. Sindy (Hsinyi) Peng and her student, Roy (my interpreter), and Mei-Ya and her daughter, Michelle, and others took me to dinner. Sindy drove me to the airport. She was a major help! She coordinated all the details. I owe her bigtime! Seems she has been reading my research. That makes 19 or 20 people in the Bonk fan club. My mom and my Uncle Art were the first ones in.
Part 2: Thailand. I got to Thailand late that night--to keynote an e-learning conference in Bangkok which started the next day. Had fun there too. Met up with former student Kevin Koury who is now an endowed chair in Pennsylvania. It was great to catch up. Randy Garrison from the University of Calgary was also there to keynote as was Nada Dabbaugh from George Mason University. Thitinun (Ta) Boonseng, a student from the University of Missouri was a big help! Ta made sure all the keynotes had fun. So many pictures taken at this conference! Many volunteers to help make this one run smoothly.
Thailand was simply wonderful. While there, I got to tour Bangkok and a wonderful golden temple. You must see it! Also had a monk attend one of my talks and a former monk show me around Chiang Mai. Got to the international floral festival there as well. Many pics. It was like EPCOT in Orlando--many cultures of the world on display.
And I had my 28th b-day when in Bangkok on the 16th. Many people celebrated my bday with me in Bangkok. Entire conference sang happy bday at the closing ceremony and I got an official watch from the King’s bday. Many bands playing at night—my friend Ta had them sing happy bday to me at each pub we visited. What a good time that was! My final stop was Mahasarakham University for 2 talks on December 20th. They had many educational technology students in the audience.
I just got home at noon on the 21st of December (yesterday). Had to fly from Mahasarakham University (a university NE of Bangkok where I had 2 final talks) to Bangkok and then to LAX and then to Chicago and then to Indy. LAX was a zoo and a 6 hour layover. In LA, I sat next to a woman who sorta snuck onto the plane on standby and she would not get off and so after 45 minutes of officials trying to get her to walk off, they called security to take her off. This caused me to be almost late for my flight from Chicago to Indy. They were calling my name for last call as I ran there from another terminal at O'Hare. One bag made it and one did not. Still waiting--the one I am missing has my xmas gifts bought in Chiang Mai which I saw in LAX so I know it made it to the USA. What a terrible trip home but at least I slept nearly the entire time from Bangkok to LA.
I really enjoyed this trip though I am very tired. Ate too much to keep up my energy! I gained almost 10 pounds. I may go back to Taiwan for Wikimania in August.
Some overall reflections. Let's try for 10... #1. The Asian culture is very special and helpful. I had more support than any trip I have ever taken. Yes, some of it was from former students but much of it was from people I had never met before in my life. This makes the 24 hours of flying worthwhile perhaps.
#2. I want to continue to learn more about the Buddhist religion. I have been given many books on this religion lately. Perhaps it is a sign. Perhaps Bonk should become a Monk. (Bonk the Monk, who would have thunk?)
#3. Many Asian countries look at e-learning as an area for economic growth and a way to spur educational change. It will be interesting to see which country will be the e-learning leader in 2010--will it be Korea, China, Taiwan, Japan, Malaysia, Singapore, or Thailand or someplace else? What will a leader role look like?
#4. Blended learning is a concept that is intriguing in Asia but still remains fuzzy with many misunderstandings. Someone could make money consulting on blended learning in Asia. Where will blended learning make its greatest impact--higher education, K-12 schools, government settings, or corporate training?
#5. Taiwan is posed to take a leadership role in the e-learning space and in educational technology in general. Much interest and momentum. But to date, more talk than action; at least, according to our research on blended learning in corporate training.
#6. The open university of Ramkhamhaeng in Bangkok has more than 600,000 students. When will a university reach over a million students? 2 million? As education opens up for learners in remote and not so remote regions of the world, what will happen? How will this change learning as we know it?
#7. Many universities in Taiwan and Thailand are starting to offer Ph.D.'s in educational technology and learning sciences. How will this impact Ph.D. programs in ed tech, learning sciences, and instructional systems technology in the USA? Will my program be negatively affected? I think the emergence of new universities and program in Taiwan has already impacted my program at IU. Not as many students from there today as we had when I started in 1992.
#8. Despite observations made in #7 above, there continue to be students who approach me about coming to the USA for study either for master's, Ph.D., or a post-doc. I know we cannot handle all of them. How to help all these requests? Humm...
#9. During the conference in Bangkok, many people approached me about keynoting regional and international e-learning conferences they are organizing in such places as the Phiippines, Thailand, Indonesia, and elsewhere that will be held in 2007. It certainly seems to be the hot topic of the year in Asia as it was in the USA 5 years ago. Are they just catching up or is this a new wave of interest? Should I commit to keynoting them since this many not last long or take a pass on them and rest up? Hard to say what to do but I am tired from flying home for 24+ hours so perhaps I just learn to say no more often.
#10. The audiences for my talks vary widely. If a department advertizes the talk to the university, often people from other depts will not attend since they think it does not apply. If the university announces it, the people come from all over the campus. And it might be the same talk. Overall, the audiences have been varied and they have been packing the rooms. Many graduate students have been attending my talks which is good to see. I was fortunate to have nearly every talk go well in Taiwan and Thailand. For this I am highly thankful! May this momentum continue into the new year!!!!!
Bonus observation: Presentations at the e-learning conference in Bangkok from Randy Garrison from the University of Calgary in Canada, Nada Dabbaugh from GMU in the USA, and Dr. Said Hadjerrouit of Agder University College in Norway (as well as my own) indicate that people are increasingly considering the pedagogy behind e-learning. This is an important trend for higher education. Nada, Randy, and Said each are developing pedagogical frameworks for reflecting on e-learning. One might take a look at their work. I wonder if IT people in universities will take notice or continue to simply ask IT questions and look at and promote computer log data for their answers. I also wonder if corporate people will also begin to look at pedagogy and online interaction instead of just seek technology solutions.
God bless everyone this holiday season and into 2007. |
|
|
|
|
|
|